They Built a Hit but Can’t Keep It?
Tracy and Toni are grooming pros with 27 years of hands-on experience. After dealing with anxious, stressed-out dogs during blow-dry sessions for way too long, they finally had enough. So, they invented a soft, stretchy ear hoodie to calm pets down during noisy, high-pressure grooming. It’s been a massive hit ever since.
Most buyers agree it works like a charm. It’s simple, functional, and solves a real problem. But after digging into the patent records, we discovered their utility patent never actually got approved. Which explains why the market flooded with designs that look almost identical, some are straight-up copy-paste.
First, Let’s Look at the Function
As sellers, we know a good product solves a real pain point. But does that always translate into patent protection? Time to look at it from the ground up. Let’s go back to the product from its functional perspective. Dogs and cats have far more sensitive hearing than humans. So when a high-powered dryer is blasting right next to their ears, it’s no wonder they freak out. For especially nervous or sound-sensitive dogs, stress can turn into full-on panic.
Through rounds of trial and error, Tracy and Toni arrived at a smart yet simple solution: a soft, stretchy earband that gently presses the dog’s ears down, helping close off the ear canal and block out the noise. It’s not complicated but works pretty well. And that’s kind of the point.
When we took a closer look at the patent file, it became clear. The simple-but-effective design likely lacked strong technical novelty. Most of the claims focused on using flexible fabric and an elastic band to cover the ears, rather than introducing a distinctive structural design or a measurable performance advantage. The physical wrap to reduce noise just didn’t meet the bar for true innovation. And without that, there’s no real protection to fall back on.
Sourcing From a Sportswear Supplier
The product itself is a stretchy band. And as we kept digging, we found their supplier was a Taiwan sports manufacturer that typically makes athletic headbands. In other words, the supply chain is easy to access. There was nothing stopping competitors from producing similar products, especially with a product that was already proving to have solid market demand.
Meanwhile, the innovative concept opened the door for other sellers to jump in. Now, if you look on Amazon, you’ll find many pet ear muffs that look just like Happy Hoodie. Some with velcro straps, others using elastic cords. Some sellers just adapted human noise reduction ear muffs for pets.
Fresh Design, Smarter Protection
But there’s always a way to break through even with a product that’s tough to patent. This year, a breakout brand called Doggie Hush found their sweet spot. Instead of imitating existing designs, their team launched something fresh: a triangular, headphone-style ear cover that blocks out noise without squishing the dog’s ears.
It’s pretty eye-catching. And more importantly, they secured a design patent early on, and that became their edge. With the design locked in, Doggie Hush held their $49 price point while confidently investing in branding, marketing, and scaling. Over 4,000 units sold in just 73 days on Amazon alone. Smart distribution, targeted ads, and growing social media buzz fueled the momentum. Thanks to early patent protection, there were no copycats to slow them down.
Subscribe
Subscribe to us to see more case studies like this one, plus product ideas, startup stories, insights, and China sourcing stories.
Wholesale and Cutsomize
Have great product ideas but not sure where to start? Or maybe you’re looking to buy products in stock, add your logo, customize packaging, or place a small order for quick testing?
Share your ideas. Get affordable, and effective sourcing solutions!
